The Help, Redux

OK, now.  So, The Help opened solidly–$25.5 million over the weekend, $35.4 since Wednesday. Time magazine had perhaps the most unfortunate headline of this news: Apes Fight Off the Help. The prequel to Planet of the Apes just bested –at 27.5m–the film about Black domestic workers in the pre-civil rights South. And it was the South that gave the film its biggest support–places like Memphis, Atlanta, Dallas, and Jackson, Mississippi, the locale of the (allegedly fictional) story.

I posted about this film before the opening (see below Going to the Movies–at The White House) but feel a couple of notes necessary after the volumes of protest from, most notably the Association of Black Women Historians, which issued a formal statement:

…The Help distorts, ignores, and trivializes the experiences of black domestic workers. We are specifically concerned about the representations of black life and the lack of attention given to sexual harassment and civil rights activism.

The Association goes a step more, by giving a reading list to help us put the situation in historical context.(

The controversy surrounding the film makes clear how fundamentally important media is, no matter how small or large. And I’ve begun to believe that The Help is too frail a project to carry the weight of emotions that  have erupted around it.

For one thing, I’m disturbed by some insulting descriptions of domestic workers–by those opposing the film’s portrayals. I would hate to think that in defending Black women, we must disparage the hard working, honorable women who did, and still do (to the tune of 2.5 million mostly women of color) support whole  families, raise children and send them off to college by working as domestics. I suggest that in addition to words, we all send a contribution to Ai Jen Poo’s National Domestic Worker Alliance for its work in New York and California (still pending) and internationally  to establish minimum wages and fair working conditions for domestic workers. (

Secondly, let’s take seriously our own roles in film, television, online, publishing by supporting the positive projects and boycotting the negative ones…no matter who makes them. That means showing up on opening night for films and using our social networking tools to bring other folks to the theater. And it means aggregating responses to networks and film studios in a prompt, consistent manner.

The stakes are too high to let the energy unleashed by this one small movie (alright, and one big book) dissipate.






Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s